The Classification of services is no more than a theoretical importance. With reference to any services classification scheme, critically examine this statement.
Kotler defines services as any
activities or benefits that one party can offer to another that is essentially
intangible and does not result in the ownership of anything. He goes on to say
that its production may or may not be tied to a physical product. Palmer
(1994) defines services as the production of essentially intangible benefit
either in its own right or as a significant element of a tangible product which
through some form of exchange satisfies an identified consumer need. According to Wikipedia (1996a)A service is
the non-material equivalent of a good. A service is any act or
performance that one party offers to another that is essentially intangible and
does not result in the ownership of anything.
Kotler(2000)Services are intangible, inseparable,
variable, and perishable. These aspects affect the design of the marketing
management framework. Each characteristic poses challenges and requires certain
strategies. Marketers must find ways to give tangibility to intangibles, to
increase the productivity of service providers, to increase and standardize the
quality of the service provided, and to match the supply of services during
peak and nonpeak periods with market demand.
Intangibility
Palmer (1994 ) states that “a pure service cannot be
assessed using any of the physical senses. Services are intangible. This allude
to the fact that services cannot be touched or viewed. Unlike physical
products, they cannot be seen, tasted, felt, heard, or smelled before they are
bought. This poses a challenge for clients to tell in advance what they will be
getting. Services are ideas and concepts
that are part of a process. The client typically relies on the service
providers’ reputation and the trust they have with them to help predict
quality-of-service and make service choices. Regulations and governance are
means to assuring some acceptable level of quality-of-service. It is the
duty of the service marketer to tangibilize the intangible through the physical
evidence. The person who is getting a face lift cannot see the exact
results before the purchase, just as the patient in the psychiatrist’s office
cannot know the exact outcome before treatment.
To reduce uncertainty, buyers
will look for signs or evidence of the service quality. They will draw
inferences about quality from the place, people, equipment, communication
material, symbols, and price that they see. Therefore, the service provider’s
task is to “manage the evidence,” to “tangibilize the intangible.”Whereas product
marketers are challenged to add abstract ideas, service marketers are
challenged to add physical evidence and imagery to abstract offers. This is why
Allstate uses the slogan “You’re in good hands with Allstate.”In
general, service marketers must be able to transform intangible services into
concrete benefits. For example, Marketers in service companies use
sensory evidence and the development of strong brands in reducing uncertainty,
hence reducution of perceived risk is
evident. service marketer is to stimulate personal influence sources such as
word of mouth which is normally an non-paid form advertising. Celebrities and
other famous people may be used in this regard for instance Phillip Chiyangwa.
Inseparability
Kotler(2000)Services are typically produced and consumed
simultaneously, unlike physical goods,
which are manufactured, put into inventory, distributed
through resellers, and consumed
later. If a
person or a machine renders the service, then the provider is part of the
service for instance service of bank ATMs can only be enjoyed if the producer
and consumer interact. In the extreme case of personal care services-high
involving, the customer must be present during the entire process (a doctor
cannot provide a service without the involvement of the patient). This is not
true for physical goods that are manufactured, put into inventory, distributed
through multiple resellers and consumed still later (Kottler, 2000)
Because the client is also present as the service is
produced, provider-client interaction
is a special feature of services marketing—both provider
and client affect the
outcome. As tangible clues, service providers are
evaluated based on their use of language, clothing, personal hygiene and
interpersonal communication skills. Marketers should strive to create
performance teams which Goffman defined as a set of individuals who cooperate
to create a single definition of reality (Goffman, 1959,p, 79). The
implications on marketing management is that staff has to be trained to interact
effectively with clients, look for ways to prevent other customers from
disturbing others. Often, buyers of
services have strong provider preferences. Several strategies exist for getting
around this limitation. One is higher pricing in line with the provider’s
limited time. Another is having the provider work with larger groups or work
faster.
An alternative strategy is to train more service providers
and build up client confidence. Service providers also have to put emphasis on
selecting and training public contact personnel. Since public personnel are
part of the service experience their emotions and attitudes are apparent to the
customer and can affect the service experience for better or for worse. It is
essential to build trust and teamwork and making employees loyal to the
company’s mission. Employees must also be trained in ‘soft’ management skills
such as reliability, responsiveness, empathy, assurance and managing the
tangibles that surround the service in order to achieve service quality
Attempting to balance consumer needs with efficient
operating procedures is a delicate art this is because it entails effectively
managing different market segments with different needs within a single service
environment. However, effective customer management can minimize this
challenge. For example, separating smokers from non smokers in a restaurant
will help create a conducive environment for different customer segments Below
is an illustration of how hotel service companies have dealt with separating
production and consumption. Here there is no direct interaction of production
and consumption where customers interact with the facilitating medium (Hoffman,
2001).
Inventorability
Kotler(2000)Services cannot be stored and are produced on
demand and in the presence of a consumer, that is, they are perishable. The
in-inventorability nature of service calls upon the service organization to
manage demand and capacity. Services can not be saved, their unused capacity
cannot be reserved. Inability to
inventory creates profound difficulties for marketing services.
To match fluctuating demand, down time can be scheduled
during periods of low demand to avoid breakdowns during peak periods, using
part time employees in services such as the bank or supermarkets where demand
sky rocket during festive seasons. Alternatively a firm may rent or share extra
facilities and equipment to avoid over investment in assets. A theatre company
can rent or hire part of its premises during the week when their demand is low
to companies who might need to conduct seminars. Employees can be cross trained
so that during peak times, some can assist frontline personnel as an example in
banks or help back office personnel to balance off books during periods of low
demand.
Inconsistency
Because services depend on who provides them and when and
where they are provided,
they are highly variable. Knowing this, service firms can
take three steps toward
quality control. The first is recruiting the right service
employees and providing them
with excellent training. This is crucial regardless of
whether employees are highly
skilled professionals or low-skilled workers
who visits MaterDei Hospital
to have an operation or tooth extraction. However, simply classifying the above
on a single service classification may leave out the fact that the person has
to go to the service provider (another service classification scheme examined
later in this essay). Also education services for instance, are an intangible
service directed at persons’ mind (Intangible action). Other examples of
services delivery classifications delivered to the person include services of
Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC) and services of Standard Chartered Bank.
In a restaurant like Chicken Inn, the customer receives both the intangible
action and tangible action
Under the question of type of
relationship that the service provider provides, services can be classified as
either consumer or producer services. This is summarized by Luvlock in the
diagram overleaf.
Membership relationship No formal relationship
Continuous Relationship
|
Insurance, Telephone, Banking
|
Radio (ZBC), Police Station
|
Discrete Relationship
|
Subscriptions for Clubs, theaters
|
Services provided by telephone and
electricity service providers are continuous services meaning the consumer can access
them at any given time. According to Luvlock, the service can either be offered
on a membership relationship or no formal relationship basis. The services
offered by radio service providers are an example of services where there is no
formal relationship between the producer and the customer. The point that
Luvlock is highlighting in the matrix above is that classifying a service as
continuous alone may leave out the aspect of whether it has a membership or no
formal membership relationship.
Services may also be classified as
either producer or consumer based. Zimbabwe ’s telephone service
provider Net One for instance, may offer a contract mobile telephone line to
NUST as a producer service. However, the same line can also be used for
personal telephone calls which are a consumer service. The matrix therefore
attempts to solve the overlapping of service classification in a real world.
Services can also be classified
according to degree of customization and judgment as illustrated below.
Extent of service customisation
Extent of customer contact High Low
High
|
Legal services, tutorials, taxi
services.
|
Teaching in a large class
(mass customisation)
|
Low
|
Hotel room service, retail
banking, telephone services
|
Public transport, fast food
restaurants and movie theatres
|
Unlike physical products, services
are created as they are consumed and the customer usually is involved in the
service production process (Core production of services). For other services
like musical concert and entertainment, there is co consumption that is all
customers enjoy the service at the same time. Due to the nature of such services
as taxi and legal services, the need for high degree of customization and
contact is of paramount importance. In contrast, although teaching a large
class may require a high degree of customer contact, the degree of service
customisation is lower. Someone who orders food at Holiday Inn on room service
will get low customer contact just like the one in a movie theater. However,
the two services differ in that the former requires lower customisation
compared to the former.
According to the traditional classification
schemes, services may also be classified as either marketable or unmarketable.
However, services that used to be unmarketable like care of the elderly and
child minding/care are now highly commercialized in the practical service
industry today. There are now a lot of Child Care Agencies that are placing advertisements
in the newspapers. Parastatals like Zimpost, Grain Marketing Board (GMB) and
government Ministries like the Ministry of Heath and Child Welfare are now
heavily competing or cooperating with the private sector in aggressive
advertisement of their products and services.
According to methods of service
delivery, some services wait for customers to come to them or with others, the
customer has to personally go to the service provider. This aspect of High or
Low Contact was briefly highlighted at the beginning of this essay, but
however, another factor that can separate that is, either ingle site or
multiple sites. This is illustrated overleaf.
DELIVERY
METHOD
Single site multiple
sites
Customer goes to the organisation
|
Barber shop, movie
|
Fast food Chains (Chicken Inn),
bus service
|
Organization goes to the customer.
|
Taxi , lawn mowing and pest
control
|
Mail delivery
|
Both transact at arms length
|
Credit card
|
Telephone
|
The example of a barber here for
the second time shows the practical overlapping of theoretical service classifications. As shown above, some
services require the customer to go to the service provider either on a single
site or multiple sites. In the developed
world for instance, one can catch an inter-city bus shuttle on multiple sites
at multiple sites. On contrary, taxi, lawn mowing and pest control services
require the service provider to go to the customer to provide the service. For
example, the over grown grass on NUST grounds will necessitate the service
providers like the local authority tractors to visit the client to perform the
service.
Services unlike physical products
can not be stocked which a character of uninventoribility. According to the
classification which answers the question of the nature of demand and supply,
service providers like hotels and restaurants can not recover the lost revenue
once there is no one who comes to have lunch or if thee rooms are empty on a
given day the revenue is lost forever. Pattern of demand vary from hourly,
monthly, seasonally or yearly according to the industry.
Extent
of fluctuations over time
Wide Narrow
Peak demand can be met without delay
|
Electricity, telephone, maternity
clinic
|
Insurance, legal services and
banking
|
Peak demand exceeds capacity
|
Hotels, restaurants, theatres
|
As illustrated above services
providers like ZESA and Net One for instance, may be able to quickly adjust
their supply to meet demand in the short run unlike hotels and restaurants that
are not able to expand supply (rooms capacity) in the short run should peak
demand exceeds supply.
Service classifications in a
practical world tend to overlap and the theoretical applications do not always
apply on single classifications. To solve this challenge, Luvlock classified
the services using cluster analysis and this is also supported by Solomon and
Gould (1991) who says that theoretical classifications normally combines two or
more of the traditional classifications.
BIBILOGRAPHY
Marketing Management 7th Edition: Phillip Kotler
Principles of Services Marketing 1st Edition: Palmer A
Services Marketing 2nd Edition: Luvlock
Comments
Post a Comment